When I posted this on Facebook, it was simply because I couldn’t fit my frustration and sadness about the discussion to the 140 Twitter characters or even the 450 that Facebook allows. And when some of the responses seemed to say “Thank You for giving us a voice…” I figured that there were probably more people who needed to hear it. And it’s scary to be bold, to be vocal about such a contentious topic, but I believe it’s important, too.
I wanted a different voice to be heard. The voice of pain and experience. A voice that values the humanity, struggle, lives and hurt of the women who need an organization like Planned Parenthood. Those disenfranchised and left to fend for themselves.
Planned Parenthood seems to be the ugly kid that gets kicked around after school when it comes to political discussions. I understand that a lot of people object and think of Planned Parenthood as an abortion mill. I get that. I do.
But that’s not nearly the entire story. We hear harrowing tales of the young women who are scared and arrive at Planned Parenthood only to be convinced that they need to murder their children by these evil doctors who have this deeply twisted plan to do as many abortions as possible. We see protesters standing outside the clinics with traumatizing posters of aborted, bloody fetuses. We hear of doctors who are sick and disturbed fulfilling their sociopathic urges at the clinics. But we don’t hear about the others. The women who depend on Planned Parenthood for survival.
The women like me.
When I was 18-25, I was living the very cliché ‘at-risk’ lifestyle everyone talks about. I'm not proud of that, but there you go. Drugs, sex and alcohol were all part of the package. I wanted to escape. I needed to be wanted. I swam in a blissful bath of self-devastation, believing that if I could just be beautiful enough, funny enough, charming enough and providing the party enough, somehow I would find something to fill the emptiness that was my life. I wasn’t paying attention to taking care of myself, really. I just wanted to feel something. Anything. And the only way I could do that was to live as far on the edge as I could possibly stand.
I somehow in the midst of this found a strange discipline. Every six months, I went into Planned Parenthood. And while there, I received a full exam, bloodwork, screenings for every possible imaginable problem, and contraception. They were compassionate and helpful, and seemed keen to help me make wise choices. Most of the time they continued to encourage me to stop living that lifestyle. They encouraged me to stop doing drugs, to stop sleeping around. And the counselor really wanted me to see myself as having value and worth without that behaviour. But they never penalized me for my choices. They continued to provide care in combination with counseling. Hoping that I would eventually make wise choices.
They didn’t see me as the whoring, boozy junkie that I was.
At a time when some in my church had used those words to cast me out and send me further into my behaviour, they treated me like the hurting, broken, wounded young woman that I was.
I can remember the day I stopped going to my regular appointments. It was the day I knew that I was pregnant. I wanted an easy solution, not a lengthy diatribe about choices and ethical decisions and cleaning up my life or the responsibility of a family and taking care of it wisely. So I went elsewhere. And surprisingly, the healthcare provider I had - although they refused to cover the cost of the pill (cost covered by PP) - they paid the entire bill for the other procedure without blinking. After all, IT WAS CHEAPER. It was cheaper and a better 'business' decision to pay a few hundred bucks if a young woman got in trouble than to pay the long term care of prevention.
I know it sounds incredulous. I know it doesn’t make logical sense.
Imagine being a young woman. Encouraged by all industries that she is a sex object. That she is not attractive or desirable unless she’s sleeping with or leading on various men. Then compound that with the knowledge that 9 times out of 10, men won’t provide a condom. They can’t be bothered. It doesn’t feel good. “You’re on the pill, right?” Add to all of that the knowledge that men don’t have the same nine-month consequence that women do. The expectation is all on the woman. But the blame, the shame, the dehumanization is also on the woman.
A badge of pride to notch a bedpost, but a mark of shame to be on the pill.
And all of the financial repercussions fall to the woman. If the man steps up – which thankfully, often happens – then the burden is shared. But the man does not lose wages due to morning sickness. The father doesn’t have to worry about unpaid maternity leave. The costs of prenatal care, setting up the nursery. These all add up. And the overall cost of self-esteem and dreams lost as she is ridiculed and often exiled because she did what the world told her to do – but got caught with the consequences.
If you don't want to believe me, I can tell you that it happened a second time. Years later, when my insurance refused to cover the contraception, they jumped at the chance to pay for an abortion - this time at a highly priced, specialized expert office. Planned Parenthood had been once again paying for my contraception, although I had forgotten to take it. My responsibility, my mistake, but they were the ones attempting to care for me.
When I had no money, they took none.
When I had little money, they never took more than insurance would cover.
People brand them the abortion mill, because they support choice and offer legal and safe options for those women who make the 'wrong' or 'sinful' choice (like I did).
As I said earlier, I’m not proud of the decisions that I made. But to be fair, I’ve had to make that decision to end a pregnancy, and never once been counseled by Planned Parenthood to do so.
The only counsel I’ve received from them has been to stop living a reckless life. To slow down and pursue things in life that mattered and brought life. Something that the church couldn’t find in itself at the time to do. They could only see me for the drug-addicted promiscuous lifestyle I was leading, while the counselors at Planned Parenthood tried to see me as part of a bigger, more important story. They treated me as a human being – valuable and worthy of respect and help.
For those who think that I should have received my punishment for my actions… Maybe I should have contracted AIDS or been forced to have a child. Perhaps I could have been enslaved to other people’s value systems in order to prove a point.
But that doesn’t speak ‘kingdom’ to me. That doesn’t speak ‘grace’ to me. That doesn’t tell me that I am valued and that for some reason the Creator of the Universe desires for me to live and thrive in His presence.
I have a chance to live and have children and be a part of this amazing grace-filled, kingdom-oriented story that I am a part of. Because of Planned Parenthood.
I understand that people have issues with tax dollars going to abortion.
I have significant issues with my tax dollars going to the military-industrial complex. I have a feeling that more people have died because of those tax dollars than ever will be through abortion – and not just unborn children, but grown children. Women, pregnant and otherwise, men, people with full lives both behind and in front of them.
But I still pay my taxes. I recognize that my values are different than others.
But I also contribute time, energy, and money to interfaith and reconciliatory non-violent organizations that are working to promote peace in the world through peaceful, non-military means. Groups that bring together people from war-torn and violent areas and teach them peace.
How many of those objecting to their tax dollars being spent on this organization contribute time, money, and energy to providing prenatal care and counseling for young mothers? Or how many of them adopt young women into their homes and care for them during their pregnancies and afterwards, with no expectation of reward?
I’ve done so. And it was a brilliant experience. Looking at precious Babbins gets me every time, because I know that her mom was able to look the future in the eye knowing that she would not be abandoned by society or others because her decision did not fit some values mold. I know that I gave out of myself to bring life into the situation. I gave the mother a REAL choice.
If we are pro-life, we need to also recognize that the life of the mother has value. That the life of the child has value after it is born. And we need to be committed to providing that if we want to take away from the organizations that do so.
Planned Parenthood is caring for a generation (or 2 or 3) AND their children while encouraging them to live more responsible lifestyles in which the choice to have an abortion doesn't need to be made.
In all of my encounters with them, prevention of unwanted pregnancy and disease, wellness and health, responsible choices and maturity - these were their goals.
Perhaps others have had other experiences. If someone walks into a Planned Parenthood office with the idea that they need an abortion and they state it as it is, perhaps they will see the organization as 'mill'.
But for the poor, the broken, those living in such an at-risk lifestyle, I cannot help but have compassion. I remember that I, too, lived like that, but came out of it into a place of health and maturity.
By removing their funding, we penalize young women and children and show them that love and grace actually CANNOT triumph over judgment. That they are not worthy of care. That we have dehumanized them to worthless wastes of life and space.
And I simply won't be a part of that.
If you want to remove funding from Planned Parenthood, and you claim to be doing so on Christian grounds, I would strongly encourage you to make sure that there is an alternative for prenatal care and preventative family planning in your neighborhood and you start giving financially in support of them. One of the strange statistical truths is that when stigma is removed and care is provided for young women without judgment or condemnation, abortion rates decline.
When we offer a young woman support and the ability to raise a child without fear, we have fought the better fight against death, on the side of life.
I am pro-life, I grieve abortion (on a VERY personal level) and I support Planned Parenthood.